Contact

I'm always glad to hear from people who read the site.

If you're interested in talking to me for whatever reason, please feel free to contact me using the Contact form above or directly at lar@wezen-ball.com.

Oh, and don't forget, you can always use the Forums!

Follow Me

facebook_64Twitter_64rss_64

Search

Latest Forum Posts

Sporting News Baseball Guide & Record Book online
by Luke Gofannon 2010/01/08 08:45
Welcome to the Wezen-Ball.com Forums
by lar @ wezen-ball 2009/08/20 06:24

Bloguin Baseball Debate

BaseballDebateTag

Baseball Bloggers Alliance

bba-sml

Other Links

Online Flowers
Shop for your flowers online at the Online Flowers shop

Dawson's Blank Check E-mail
Written by Larry Granillo   
Thursday, 28 January 2010 06:20

There was a lot of news yesterday - from Apple's unveiling of their Personal Access Display Device (wait - am I confusing that with something?) to the President's State of the Union address - but the most interesting baseball story of the day was the news that Andre Dawson will be inducted into the Hall of Fame this summer as a member of the Montreal Expos. For my friends who are Expos fans out there, I cannot be more happy. Major League Baseball's abandonment of Montreal is still a fresh wound, and news like this is might be the only salve that they'll get in the next 20 years.

Dawson, however, is less than excited. Citing the Cubs as "what really catapulted me to Hall of Fame status", Dawson expressed his "disappointment" in the Hall's decision and hoped that his preference "would carry a little more weight than it did." When asked if he would put a Cubs hat on during his inauguration, he didn't rule it out. He was quick to say that he would never do anything "that might be an embarrassment to someone or show someone up, that's not my character."

Dawson's legacy with the Cubs seems almost exclusively to be wrapped around the 1987 season, Yes, I know he played five other years with the Cubs and went to the All-Star game in four of them, but it's all based around that '87 season, when he signed the blank contract to move to Chicago and then proceeded to blast 49 home runs and win the MVP award for the last place Cubs. It's exactly the kind of thing that would make a fanbase fall in love with a player, so we can't fault them for that.

But it got me wondering about what things were like that March of 1987. Was Dawson really as excited to move to the Cubs for a paltry $650,000 as everyone seems to remember? Could he even have been? Let's take a look.

(Click "Read More" to continue reading.)

From the March 8, 1987, Chicago Tribune, the Cubs' prepared statement, written by club president Dallas Green, was given:

"...Andre and [agent] Dick [Moss] were willing to sacrifice salary and principle in 1987 to play in Wrigley Field for the Cubs. He was willing to bet that his production on the field would better his salary for 1988 and the future --something rather unusual in itself in these wild days of free agency. Our baseball people were able to convince Tribune Co. that we as an organization could overcome the obstacles we had presented to signing him and perhaps improve the team in 1987. The rest is up to Andre and the Cub players, who were so anxious to see this accomplished.

Andre has proven once again that he is a class person. I know he is a fine player and all of us in the organization welcome him with great enthusiasm."

The Cubs were certainly excited to be getting a man at $500K guaranteed who had earlier turned down a 2-year, $2-million contract from Montreal. Ah, the joys of collusion.

And Dawson? From the same article, the statement from Dawson's agent, Dick Moss, read:

"Early Thursday afternoon Dallas Green telephoned me and formally accepted our offer to sign with the Chicago Cubs for the 1987 season. He also at that time advised us of the terms of the acceptance. In our offer on Tuesday, we stated that Andre would sign for whatever salary terms Cub management said was fair and appropriate, bearing in mind their knowledge of the salary structure in baseball and their knowledge of who Andre is.

We had hoped that the club's definition of fairness would have been more realistic, but our offer was unconditional and we will, of course, honor our commitment.

He will have the opportunity to receive additional amounts in award bonuses, but except for $50,000 for selection to the All-Star team, they probably will not be made. Andre will be paid a salary, in my opinion, less than one-half of what he would be entitled to if he were properly slotted into baseball's salary structure. However, none of this detracts in any way from his enthusiasm of joining the Cubs or his eagerness to make a contribution to the team's competitiveness...."

Yeah, he sounds enthused. There's also this quote, from the March 9, 1987, Montreal Gazette:

Andre Dawson has found a job, but yesterday the veteran outfielder didn't sound too happy about the way his free-agency experiment came out.

Interrupted by a phone call as he packed his bags to fly to Arizona, Dawson said: "I have mixed feelings about the contract. I'm not too happy with the money, but I wanted to play in Chicago, so . . ."
...
"I didn't think they'd make an offer, because I thought they didn't want to be the first ones to sign a free agent," Dawson said yesterday. "But since they did, I'm man enough to stick by it.

I know I'll miss Montreal . . . but you gotta do what you gotta do. I don't want to say a move was overdue, but with the problems I had the last couple years . . . I had the same salary the last six years, and then they offer me a pay cut . . .

It got so that towards the end of the season some of my own teammates told me it would be best that I make a change."

Let's face it: this was the era of collusion and no one was punished more by it than the dynamic duo from Montreal, Tim Raines and Andre Dawson. It is absolutely reasonable for Dawson to have been upset at the way the Cubs exploited his good faith offer that spring. But this revisionist history that the blank check was a happy compromise between the two parties, and that it signified the immediate beginning of a joyous era for the Hawk, is preposterous. It was only after Dawson took full advantage of 1987's juiced balls and Wrigley's comfy dimensions that things changed for the better, and, even then, it took a near-record-setting arbitration hearing and then a two-year contract for things to smooth over completely.

Andre Dawson has every reason - whether it be sentimental or monetary - to prefer a Cubs cap on his Hall of Fame plaque. But I think it's disingenuous to suggest that the good vibes started the minute he signed that blank contract. In the end, though, the Hall made the right choice, and I'm glad to see it. Now it'd be nice to see Tim Raines join him in Cooperstown - if for no other reason than to know that one of Montreal's three (or four - see Vlad Guerrero) potential Hall of Famers actually wanted to wear the red-white-and-blue "M" on his cap. We can only wait.



Digg! Reddit! Facebook! Technorati! StumbleUpon! BallHype: hype it up!
Comments (16)Add Comment
The Common Man
...
written by Mike, January 28, 2010
Great, great stuff, Lar. In light of the romanticizing of Dawson's decision and his "clean" career, it's nice to see someone willing to actually, you know, look into it.
0
nothing good from Dawson about Montreal
written by RobL1, January 28, 2010
I live in Montreal, was and am a huge baseball fan, but I have been truly disappointed by the comments made by Dawson during this period following the announcement of his impending Hall of Fame induction. He spent 10 years in Montreal, was adored by many thousands of Montreal fans (remember, when he was here, Montreal was regularly TOP FIVE in NL attendance)and yet he has had basically nothing good to say about his time here. Does he forget? I understand wanting to go in as a Cub, I really do, but please, please Andre, for the many, many Montreal fans who spent lots of time rooting for you and following your career during and after your time with the Expos, say something, anything nice about your time here. They were great teams, winning teams, and I don't recall the entire time being such duress for you.
0
Confused
written by Jesse G., January 29, 2010
I am a little bit confused at the way you are spinning this. If anything, the fact that he wasn't initially so enthused about the Cubs decision on his salary makes the story better, imo. I was not a proponent of Dawson going into the Hall mostly due to his OBP but this is a fantastic testimony to him as a person. He committed to playing for an indeterminate amount because his priority was to play in Chicago, he was then upset about how much money he was going to be paid, and he still went out there and dominated. Pretty great if you ask me.
0
This makes The Hawk look better, not worse...
written by edillinia, January 29, 2010
So, you looked deeper into it and find that Dawson gave props to the city of Montreal despite the team colluding against him his entire career. You also find that he did, in fact, offer a "blank contract" to the Cubs and he was a little miffed at the salary they saw fit to write in (do you think he should have demanded less money or something?). He did not let his displeasure prevent him from producing a great season. The only negative light this shines upon Dawson comes from the blogger's skewed commentary.
0
In Praise of Andre Dawson
written by Sweet Lou, January 29, 2010
First, let me say that I enjoy your blog. It's well written and even when I don't agree with you, your views are rarely unreasonable.

In this case, I'm not clear on what you are trying to say. The evidence you provide points to Andre Dawson being as much or more of a class act than his reputation already indicates.

Dawson offered the Cubs a blank check, the Cubs took undue advantage of it, and although he wasn't happy with the money, he went out and had a great year anyway. He didn't spend his time whining or feeling sorry for himself. He let his on-field performance do his talking.

Even so, you seem to be spinning this story to in some way make Dawson come off looking like the bad guy. The facts just don't support that. Am I reading you wrong?
0
...
written by mb211, January 29, 2010
What do you mean by juiced balls in 1987?
lar @ wezen-ball
Thanks for the comments, everyone.
written by lar @ wezen-ball, January 29, 2010
I'm not sure, but maybe the post is coming across as anti-Dawson. That wasn't my intention. Other than my feeling that he's being unfair to the fans of Montreal (who loved him plenty), I don't think he's ever really done anything wrong. Like everyone says, he honorably respected the undervalued contract the Cubs handed to him and turned it into an MVP season. I like Dawson, and Cubs fans have every reason to love the guy.

I'm more talking about the way today's media is treating his time with the city of Chicago. When they mention the blank check, it sounds like a cute, clever little story about how he and the team worked something out to beat the evils of collusion (and, if you listen to Hawk himself, it almost sounds like he has rosied up the memory of it in his own mind). As these articles and press releases from the time clearly show, the truth was pretty different. Yes, Dawson showed himself to be a classy man by accepting it and making the most of it, but the journey was much tougher than we're being led to believe 20+ years later. It's not a bad idea to look into it again and see what the real truth was. That's all I'm saying.
0
From The Carolinas
written by jem1776, January 29, 2010
Great stuff. I remember that blank contract like it was yesterday, but I did not have all the info. Thanks and it's wonderful to see the Hawk going into the Hall as an Expo.
0
Dawson & the Montreal Fans
written by rocky, January 29, 2010
It's the same old sad song, how angry the Expos fans are about Dawson's desire to wear a Cubs hat on his HOF Statue instead of the Expos. As I've seen on other blogs, it all comes down to respect and fan support. The MLB didn't abandon Montreal, you Fans did! All you had to do was attend the games! That was leading to that whole contraction nonsense...The stated attendance was 5K or less, and you know darn well there were around 500 in the seats. That's sad. The franchise should have been pulled! Hell, one season, there was no T.V. contract because no one could agree if the games should be done in French or English. So get off your soapboxes you alleged Montreal Baseball fans. If you'd shown up to the freaking games, there would likely still be an MLB Franchise there!
0
remember it like yesterday
written by Cjger31, January 29, 2010
Baseball teams were colluding in 1987. They were found to be in collusion against free agents and later paid a penalty to the Players' Union. Andre Dawson didn't like the salary offers in Montreal because they failed to reward him for his success and courage in playing with injury. He was forced to have several knee surgeries, probably because of the crappy artificial surface in that dome. Getting on in years, he needed a place to play ON GRASS with a team that could afford to pay him what he was worth. Dawson realized that teams were not going to sign free agents that year, as part of their illegal collusion, and he offered to play for whatever fair price the Cubs offered. No team could turn down an offer like that from a player of Dawson's ability. But initially the Cubs did, proof to any fair observer that collusion was occurring. After a considerable period of time the Cubs finally accepted this extraordinary offer. Harry Carry, the broadcaster and the final arbiter on Dawson's situation, chided the Cubs in no uncertain terms. Then the Cubs signed Dawson for $650K, an outrageously low figure. Not much to like about Major League Baseball or the Cubs or Dallas Green. A lot to like about the class act, Andre Dawson. He played that way too.
0
...
written by mb211, January 29, 2010
Lar, I don't think you were being unfair at all. I agree that Dawson's comments about the Expos are piss poor and he should be ashamed for saying them. I was more curious about the juiced ball in 1987 and have found links later on documenting it. Well written article.
berselius
...
written by berselius, January 29, 2010
For what it's worth, Dawson's people did engage in some shenanigans of their own. They didn't break through collusion strictly because they gave Dallas Green a blank contract. Dawson and Dick Moss (his agent) turned up to Spring Training unannounced, and when they tried to meet with Green his secretary pushed them aside by saying that Green was unavailable, and wouldn't be all week. So they just left an envelope with the blank contract there and told all the Cubs beat writers what they had done. Green found out from the newspapers.
0
Red, White and Blue
written by Jeff Hainey, January 30, 2010
Just so no one's confused...the good ole red, white and blue on that Montreal cap has much more to do with the French flag than the one flying in most MLB stadiums.
0
The Truth
written by bobbailey, January 30, 2010
Everyone knows that Dawson was awesome with the Expos. Everything was better than with the Cubs. Contender with the Expos, loser with the Cubs. Every possible stat calculated is better with the Expos. Better Expos teams, worse Cubs teams. No brainer Dawson in the Coop as a Montreal Expo.
0
Blah, Blah, Blah
written by niko68, January 31, 2010
Why are some of you turning this into a PISSING MATCH?!?!?!

First and foremost, great article Larry!

For the rest of you assclowns that want to start these pissing matches about which city is better, this is the wrong post for that!! And shame on you Montreal fans that have nothing better to write other than calling Cubs losers. Yeah, we know that they haven't won the big show in over 100 years....but, hey, at least they still have a franchise playing every year....and shame on those of you blaming the Expos fans for losing their team due to poor attendance.......the reason they left was a mixture of different things, so, stop with all the fan bashing hatred between the two of you fan bases!

I've been a Cubs fan for the past 35 years and although Andre's Avg, Avg # of Hr's and Avg # of Rbi's were higher as a Cub than they were as an Expo, and even though he was in the MVP voting 4 out of the 6 yrs as a Cub compared to only 5 out of the 10 yrs as an Expo, I think he really made a name for himself while with Montreal and I think the HALL OF FAME made the right call. But, I will leave you with this; if he didn't put up the numbers he did with the Cubs, would he of still made the HOF??? Probably not or not this fast.....just chew on that for a minute!
0
...
written by Boca, February 05, 2010
As a mild baseball fan, I learned nothing new here. However, is it fair to blame the fans in Montreal? Didn't their attendance go from among the highest to among the lowest? Perhaps there were other factors beyond the simple?

Write comment

busy
 

About Bloguin

Bloguin is the revolutionary blog network specifically focused on helping bloggers get the most out of their websites. We're currently working on building a large network of online communities and hope to expand our blogging coverage to include a wide range of topics.

Advertisers

The Bloguin Network allows advertisers to promote their products and services to our ever-growing number of visitors. We offer both site-specific ad placements as well as the ability to run a network-wide campaign. If you're interested in working with Bloguin to meet your advertising needs, please contact us.

Bloggers Wanted

The Bloguin Network is always looking to expand. We're specifically looking for blogs in the sports, entertainment, and video games field, but are open to adding any type of quality site. If you're a blogger and interested in joining our network, please fill out our application form.

The Bloguin Login

The Bloguin Login gives you full access to everything our network has to offer. Your name and password will work for each and every one of our sites. Signing up is simple, and will allow you to post in all our forums, create member blogs, and access other cool features! What are you waiting for? Create an Account!